top of page
Search

Why Your Menu Prices Are Leaking, Even When the Room Is Full

Oct 31
3 min read

A full dining room tells you people want your food. It does not tell you whether your menu prices still work.


When ingredient costs creep up and portions drift, a popular dish can leave less money behind every week. The sales look healthy. The money available for wages, rent and everything else quietly gets thinner.


The useful question is simple: what does this plate cost today, and what is left from its selling price?


Start with the plate you actually serve


Menu costing starts with the recipe, the portion and the latest supplier invoice. Include the sauce, cooking oil, side, garnish and bread that leave the kitchen with the order. A protein cost on its own is not a whole plate cost.


Write down whether weights are raw, trimmed or cooked. Six ounces purchased is not automatically six ounces ready to serve. If a recipe loses weight during trimming or cooking, measure its usable yield rather than treating the full purchased weight as sellable food.


A practical first check is to watch one normal plate being built. Compare it with the recipe card. An extra handful of cheese or a different scoop can make the costing sheet describe a dish your kitchen no longer serves.


How a small chicken price change adds up


Here is an illustrative example, not a customer result. All amounts are CAD.


Chicken rising from $4.10 to $4.85 per pound takes a six-ounce purchased-weight portion from $1.5375 to $1.81875, rounded to $1.54 and $1.82. The calculation is invoice price per pound × 6 ÷ 16.


The unrounded increase is $0.28125 per portion. At 300 portions a week for 52 weeks, that is $4,387.50, or about $4,400 in additional annual ingredient spending if price, portion and volume stay constant. That example excludes trim and cooking losses and covers only the chicken component.


It is not a forecast of lost net profit. It shows why a change that looks small on one invoice deserves attention on a high-volume dish.


Check the dollars as well as the percentage


Ingredient food cost percentage is the plate's ingredient cost divided by its selling price before sales tax, multiplied by 100.


The dollars remaining after ingredients still have work to do. They must help cover labour, occupancy, utilities, fees and other operating costs. Calling that remainder profit gives you a false sense of security.


A high food cost percentage is a reason to investigate. It does not, by itself, prove a dish loses money overall. A lower percentage does not prove the restaurant is profitable either.


Pick one dish and make the next decision concrete


Choose a strong seller, a dish with an expensive ingredient, or an item whose portion has become inconsistent. Gather its recipe, invoices and recent sales count. Rebuild its ingredient cost and compare that with the current price.


Then consider the choices together: correct accidental overportioning, reduce avoidable waste, test another purchase specification, adjust the recipe thoughtfully, or review the menu price. Protect what the guest values. A cheaper plate that disappoints people creates a different problem.


Put a date on the updated costing. Link shared ingredients to every recipe that uses them so the next supplier change does not disappear into a folder.


Common questions


Can a busy restaurant still lose money?


Yes. Revenue must cover more than food. Labour, overhead and other costs can exceed what sales leave after ingredients, even when the room is busy.


What do I need for a useful menu cost check?


Your menu, current invoices, recipes or batch quantities, portion sizes and usable yields. Sales counts help show which changes have the biggest weekly impact.


Start with one dish


Fix That Dish's remote service is led by consulting chef Erik Hoflick. The free one-dish menu check starts with your menu and invoices; we pick the item to investigate. It is one per restaurant. The two-business-day clock starts after the selected item's recipe, portions or batch data arrives.


If your recipes and portions are still in your head, the Recipe and Portion Guide explains the separate step for getting them written down.



Keep reading



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page